Subject: [FFML] Re: [R1/2] For Better or For Worst-Case Scenario, Ch. 3
From: RaeMowse@aol.com
Date: 3/17/2005, 6:02 AM
To: gab_ab@edsamail.com.ph, ffml@anifics.com

 
 
In a message dated 3/17/2005 2:29:48 A.M. Eastern Standard Time,  
gab_ab@edsamail.com.ph writes:
 
project's out the way -- rushed putting that note out, and forgot I  had  
swiped a synops from MicroWord -_-;  Full story below, in  straight notebook 
 
format (the fancy text version's on  fanfiction.net).  Comments, money  
gifts, etc, 
send to  _raemowse@aol.com_ (mailto:raemowse@aol.com) 

Hello again. Before we  start with the story itself (I'm commenting on this 
as I read), let me first  note that there have been a slight improvement here 
as compared to the previous  few chapters. That done, let me just say that, 
without mincing any words,  there's still a lot of room of improvement left for 
this fic. Now don't get me  wrong, when I said that I really liked the second 
chapter of this series, I  meant it. It's just that the whole thing had a lot 
of potential, but the  presentation of the fic and the communication of ideas 
remain off, heavy-handed  and hammy in parts. There would have to be 
improvement on those parts before  this story could take off, regardless of the plot.


 
 
Welcome back.  Your comments are  especially welcomed.
 
A couple of things  beforehand...
 
The extra spaces may be just your or  my mail proggie doing funny things to 
it.  I just looked at the .txt  version and there's no extra spaces like what 
you were talking about.  So,  it's either AOL, or what you use that drops in an 
extra space at odd  times.  Sort of like how old time comics like Peanuts and 
Blondie used  exclamation points for every sentence because the printer's 
auto-correctors  would sometimes eat their periods, thinking they're stray  lines.
 
I have an overfondness for ellipses.  Working on kicking the  habit.
 
Those annoying "Nabiki's Room" breaks, I've only done because of  
fanfiction.net is quite an ass about page breaks, as it absolutely refused to  recognize 
asterisks and a couple of other methods I use.  Soon as I figure  out what 
will work on there, I'll only be so glad as to get rid of them.
 
Alternative phrases "Younger sister" "newly-made wife" etc., is the result  
of lots of earlier preprogrammed English lessons imbedded within my head.   
Really trying hard to kick that habit as well.
 
Let's go on...

fully 
intent on "thanking" Kasumi for  everything she had done.

Weird. In every Ranma fan fiction I've read,  there are at least three in 
every ten fics that pits Nabiki with Kasumi because  Kasumi always foils her 
younger sister's schemes. What gives?
 
Classically, Kasumi and Nabiki are polar  opposites, most likely by 
Takahashi's intentional design.  Kasumi is  the embodiment of traditional Japanese 
woman, whereas Nabiki's the embodiment of  the modern Japanese woman.  Needless to 
say, they will clash.  I don't  know other people's reasons, but here, Nabiki 
gets taken down a few pegs (some  would say yanked off the whole damn ladder) 
because she doesn't even consider  Kasumi would do something, which is why 
she tells all to her.

She hadn't managed three steps when a surprise crested the top of  the  
stairs.

the stairs

"Akane."

More to the  point, the scheme always involves Ranma somehow, and Akane, of 
course, gets to  be the victim of said scheme.
 
Well, who else would they care about  tormenting/protecting?  Shampoo?

Usually, it's "Oh, don't  worry about Nabiki," "She can take care  of

care of

herself,"  or 
"She'll manage."

I'd like to take this opportunity to comment  on the wonderful insight of 
Nabiki's disappointments with the Tendo family and  Soun's believable attitude 
towards her daughter.
 
Thanks.  One of the things that had  struck me about Nabiki is that she seems 
to take much more after her father in  looks and in thinking than either side 
would care to admit.  Thusly, they  will either butt heads often, or just 
stay out of the other's way.   And yes, I and my father are roughly the same way.

on the  kitchen counter.  Humming to herself, she moved over to the   
utensils, picking up the wooden cutting board, well marked from where  
countless  
blades bit into the surface, then a brown handled chef's  knife which she 
sat  
atop the last-mentioned object, tip and blade  pointing away from her body.

These reads like a boring blow-by-blow  account of a boxing match. Suggest 
livening up the prose by... Oh, I dunno,  adding a few insights and character 
thoughts here and there. Human interest,  after all, catches the reader's 
attention far more than bland descriptive  prose.
 
Will do.  After looking at it, I  could probably delete the whole thing and 
no one would really miss  it.

"Can it wait?  I was about to begin  cooking dinner."  She grabbed  the

Suggest: "I'm sorry, but I'm  busy. I still have to cook dinner. Maybe we can 
talk later, okay?"  She  grabbed the

This is Kasumi we're talking about. She's very polite. The  above sentence 
seemed too rude for the likes of Kasumi. 
 
Unintentional though it may be, after  looking at it, I think it gives a 
little more credence to her abrupt change of  demeanor in the paragraphs to come.  
An old saying goes, "It's the nice  ones you have to watch out for."

"Nothing," she finally said,  shaking her head in frustration.  "I was  just 
checking out a few inquiries from the wedding."

questions from the  wedding.

Simplify dialogue. Use 'everyday' words.
 
It some cases, I feel Nabiki would use  some bigger words to show off her 
intelligence and superiority to others,  creating a Halo effect about her 
(determining that someone who is judged to be  highly knowledgeable in one trait must 
be knowledgeable in many  others).  

He lifted up a couple of items in his  immediate vicinity.  "Looking  for

Looking for

those  little black cameras.  Hiroshi says they're about the size of a  500  
yen

a 500 yen

coin, but they can see everything!"

Oh,  yeah... This scene, IMO, is pointless.
 
You would think initially...  :D

He glanced over to her, and started getting upset.   "Geez,  Nabiki!  This 
ain't no laughing matter!  I got  enough problems now,  and

now, and

people peeking in on  
me ain't going to help me at all!"  He lifted up   the

up the

picture frames on her 
desk.

Ranma: I  mean, it's not that I'm not used to it, with you and the camera and 
all, but it  makes me uncomfortable that it's not family whose exploiting 
me... Y'know what I  mean?
 
Naabiki nodded: Only we are allowed to  exploit you mercilessly.  Now put on 
those panties.
 
Ranma then realized he'd been had  again.

The brunette fell out laughing hard.  "Oh my god you're a  riot!"   She 
rolled 
back and forth on her bed, trying to catch  her breath.  "I'm  about

"I'm about..."

Oh, and  ew.
 
Yeah... gross, but it does happen.   Not to me, of course.

to piss 
myself!  I can't  believe you're such an-"

Ranma suddenly appeared before, his  expression pensive, and thrust one hand 
 
a few inches shy of her  face.  It took a few seconds but, all traces of  
laughter  became extinct.

Though he got pissed and just barely hit her.
 
Heheh... he's been resisting the urge  since this mess started.  Although... 
:wicked smile:

She  was breathless again, but for different reasons.  "Someone put a   
camera

a camera

in my room."

Well, whaddyaknow. Didn't  expect that. Cool.
 
Yeah.  Not quite a GTO-level twist,  but that should catch many by surprise.

Nabiki hung up the  handset and looked over the information she scribbled  
down on the  pad by the phone.  "Okay, Mugen says this camera model has a   
radius

a radius

Oh, and a arcade fighting game maker program is  telling her about the camera?
 
Of all the random Japanese names I pulled  out of thin air-

"Call it a hunch.  If it was me trying  to get some private shots of  
someone,

of someone

I'm get  as close as I could without attracting attention, so I could  make  

could make

Oh, and this is beginning to read like a Nabiki  bashing fic.
 
Really?  That's something I haven't  heard before.  Then again, her source 
material makes Nabiki pretty  easy to bash in fanfics.

"Dammit…" Nabiki muttered under her  breath, closing the door behind  her.

behind her

She's rather  good at blaming other people, eh?
 
Well, she's too smart for getting tripped  up like she had been, so 
naturally, it's someone else's fault.  :)

"It's Father, my son.  We're related now, so don't be  so  formal."

The younger man scratched his hear in  apology.  "Um, yeah…  Father.

How about, "Dad"?
 
See below.

Soun  snorted.  "Of course there was more.

Er, why's Soun so  irritated?
 
My interpretation of Soun does give him a  more traditional mindset, and one 
of the things  that would come up on  occasion is that grown boys do not play 
with dolls.  Gosunkugi just dropped  one, dressed up (to look like Ranma, but 
he doesn't think about these things,  nor do I think Soun even knows what a 
voodoo doll is), so thinking about  that would probably fill him up with 
contempt or disgust towards Hikaru, and to  a lesser degree the way Japan's youth of 
today lacks the virtues and values he  grew up with.  
 
In other words, he's being an  old fuddy-duddy. :)
 
Nabiki was on her knees lifting up her bed mattress again, her alert  and  
keen eyes searching for anything vaguely resembling hidden spy  equipment.   
Having been violated in such an alien way, she  was bound to leave no stone  
unturned.  In her case, every  article of clothing she owned was strewn  
across the 
room, the  dwarves

The dwarves? There are dwarves in her room.
 
I cannot begin to relate how much I dread  using that word because of Snow 
White.

"Well, who'd be  interested in videotaping us?"  She quickly cut of her   
for-now husband before he could open his mouth.  "Not  counting  'sickos.'"  
After a 
moment, she added.  "Well,  excluding the ones we  know, anyway."

Heh.
 
^_^

The sharp knock on  his room door interrupted his budding fantasy.   Sighing 
 
heavily, Gosunkugi plopped the magazine down on his desk, and  pushed  
himself 
out of his seat.  He ran his fingers through  his rumpled,  disheveled dark 
hair, mumbling just loud enough to be  heard.  "What is it,  mom?" he asked, 
opening his room  door.

He almost had a heart attack upon lighting his eyes on  Ranma and  Nabiki.  

So why didn't her mother call out to  Gosunkugi that they have some visitors?
 
She fell into a plot hole and couldn't get  up at the time.

The former looked annoyed, but the latter was  smiling, and Nabiki  Tendo - 
correction, Saotome - wearing a smile  was never a good thing.

So Nabiki asked to be registered to the Saotomes?  Seems strange, since it 
would make more sense if Ranma married into the Tendo  family (so it'd be, 
technically, Ranma Tendo). The fact that a Japanese man or  woman  can choose which 
family to marry into has been forcedly crammed in  my head care off an 
inquiring email once upon a time in FFML (waxing  nostalgic)
 
That IS something that really hasn't been  addressed, isn't it?  :)

She gave him a sly smile.   "Flattery will get you everywhere, except  one  
place."

Alcohol, on the other hand...
 
Nabiki [blushing deeply, looking  away]  So, how about them Tokyo Giants?  I 
hear they're going all the  way this year.

'Oh, trust me.  It felt so sharp and  crisp, just like it came straight  off 
the printing  press."

Heh.
 
Nabiki: [singing] "Money, it's a gas/Grab  that cash with both hands and make 
a stash"
 
She shook her head, mildly amused with his reaction.  "That's the  one  
thing 
I really want."  Her voice grew softer,  quieter.  "To not have  money 
become 
an issue."

I don't  get it.
 
And neither did Ranma, but he's getting  pretty good at smiling and nodding 
while hopping the other person will shut up  and not ask him any questions.  
Doesn't work too well in the class room,  though.


I can't believe I started talking about that, Nabiki  thought to  herself, 
as 
she kicked off her shoes at the landing and jammed her   feet into her house 
slippers.  And with Ranma, of all  people!

Wouldn't really matter, since Ranma is so... well, inattentive,  to say the 
least.
 
Ranma: [Looks up] Huh?  You talkin'  to me?

The older man nodded.  "Remember what we talked  about  yesterday."  For 
added 
effect, he flexed one arms,  pumping his fist in  front of his chest.  
""Don't' let  misfortune befall my daughter… or  else."

Heh. Half-expected demon  head Tendo to make an appearance, but this isn't 
that kind of fic.
 
The temptation is strong, but I must  resist...

Before he could ask about the tape, Nabiki  asked.  "Am I really that  
horrible a person, Ranma?"
 
"Huh?"

She rose up into a sitting position, and patted a  place beside her  
languidly.  She had not once opened her  eyes, though.  He obliged her,  
seating himself.

Awww...  drama.
 
Well, it's going to come up somewhere at  some point...

"Be honest with me here, Ranma.  Am I  really such a bitch that people  
would 
go out their way to make me  suffer for it?"

David Anderson: Yes.
 
Nabiki: [Glares] Bastard.  Who asked  you anyway?

Still leery of the extreme change that overcame  his newly-made wife,

Not only does "newly-made" wife sound awkward, it  conjures images of 
Chobits. One does not make a wife, one marries a wife.
 
Ranma: Hey, I had nothin' to with  it!  It's all the old man's fault!
 
Nabiki: [Sing-song voice] "You can  lead a horse to water, but you can't make 
him drink."  [Normal Voice]  Unlike some people I know.
 
Ranma: [looks away] So, we have a killer  soccer team this year.  We'll take 
the Cup for sure, huh?

"Just positively scandalous, wouldn't you agree, Nabiki?  It  would be  
every 
naughty pervert's dream to see you in such smutty  action, of that, I'm  
positive.  And I hear from my brother  that there are many of those kinds of 
 people 
that go to your  school.  I simply can't imagine the teachers or my  father  
taking well to catching this kind of material in their fine  student's  
hands.  
Why, I'm certain they would go so far as to  dismiss the author of  the tape.

Nasty. I've heard at least one real  life sex videotape that had the couple 
quit college in embarrassment. How, er,  timely.
 
Kodachi: Thank you for the  compliment.  I pride myself on being punctual.

"Of course  now, if you were to end up taking yourself out of this beautiful 
  
bondage of love to Ranma-sama,

I find it weird for you to have  Kodachi use '-sama' while Nabiki keeps using 
'-baby' instead of '-chan.' Pick  one... Japanese or English... for 
consistency's sake. 
 
To be honest, I couldn't think of an  English version that would give the 
same kind of reverence to him and not sound  too silly.


I'll hammer other the earlier versions a  little more finely while I work on 
outlining the next few chapters.  See  you around.



             .---Anime/Manga Fanfiction Mailing List----.
             | Administrators - ffml-admins@anifics.com |
             | Unsubscribing - ffml-request@anifics.com |
             |     Put 'unsubscribe' in the subject     |
             `---- http://ffml.anifics.com/faq.txt -----'