Subject: Re: [FFML] Let's Talk About Dialogue
From: Bob Schroeck
Date: 8/29/1998, 10:14 PM
To: guy_smiles@hotmail.com (Guy Smiles)
CC: fanfic@fanfic.com (Fanfic Mailing List)

Remember, the key rule for any dialogue is Short and Sweet. This isn't a 
matter of taste, this a rule of story-telling.. The best fanfic authors 
don't do it, and neither do any published writers.

Bull.  I *am* a published writer, of both fiction and non-fiction: books,
magazine articles and short stories.  Dialogue style is dictated by two
factors:  the needs of the story, and the personality of the character
speaking.  I've written characters who were so laconic as to be mute, and
others who spoke in paragraph-long run-on sentences -- and both were
*correct*, as determined by who they were and what they needed to say.

By this fallacious metric, you would encourage us to "improve" Hamlet's
soliloquy to "Kill myself or not?  I can't decide," and declare the
result art.

I think not.

-- =============================================================================== Robert M. Schroeck || "When in trouble or in doubt, rms@cnj.digex.net || Run in circles, scream and shout." http://www.cnj.digex.net/~rms || I have no mouse and I must scream.