Subject: Re: [FFML] [FF] Thy Outward Part
From: Sebastian Weinberg
Date: 10/29/1996, 12:10 PM
To: Fanfic Mailing List


On Sun, 27 Oct 1996, Richard Lawson wrote:

: I'd like your opinion.

Heh, I'd have given it anyway, like it or not.


: I'd also like to know what you thought of the ending.  I had intended to
: write more, but when I typed the last line, it *felt* right to stop.  If
: it's too abrupt, or if you think I should continue a little further, I
: do have some ideas in my head.

No, the point of ending was correctly chosen.


: Thy Outward Part

Would people *please* take not that *this* is the title?

Not "Thy inward Love", not "Thy outward Love" and not "Thy inward
part"!


: He'd been following her all day.  He'd skipped two classes to do it.  She
: seemed to have skipped her classes as well; after changing into the pants
: she always wore and a silk red shirt, she had spent a lot of the day walking
: around the campus, staring at the ground.

You *might* have made it more obvious by jumping up and down,
screaming "HEY! HEY, *LOOK*! IT'S *RANMA*!!"

Seriously, the shirt gave it away too soon.  If you left this
blatant flag out, the first objective proof is in the conversation
with Akane, which would make for a better story flow.


: Sensei looked at him evenly.  Finally, she gently twisted her arm out of his
: grasp.  "This ain't easy for me.  I went to college to get away from it all.
: From the pitying looks I got.  From my father, who couldn't stand the sight
: of me.  From my mother, who doesn't know and will never know that I'm her
: son.  From Akane, who stopped loving me because I'm stuck in this body.
: From everyone who knew what my problem was."

As I said somewhere else, I just can't see that reaction from
Akane.  The change would certainly have put a stop to any physical
relationship between them, but I just can't see her turning from
Ranma as soon as he stops being a boy.  I figure she would become
very supportive, not resting before she knew that Ranma was "out of
danger", so to speak.


: "I'm a guy.  Can't you get that through your thick skull?  I was born and
: raised as a guy."
: 
: Kentaro's mind raced.  "You're a person.  It's the person I'm attracted to.
: Your outward form is only secondary to the person you are underneath."

Su-u-ure, Kentaro, we believe you.  :)

Then again, Richard *is* a mind-over-matter type person.


: "As I see it, you have three options here.  You can prefer to date other
: women.  There's nothing wrong with that, although it severely limits
: your options.  I think you've learned that already with your ex-fiancee.
: You can learn to like men. 

Yeah, let's see you do that, Richard. :P  I don't think that you
can "learn" a sexual preference. 


: "Or you can continue as you have been:  yearning for something you can never
: have, keeping everyone at a distance while you wait, and ending your days
: whining, miserable and alone."

Booom.  That's gotta hurt.


: It was Ranma, he knew her in an instant.  Her hair was down around her
: shoulders, the wind tossing it lightly.  It was kept in place by a ribbon
: she'd tied in her hair.  She was wearing a white sundress, which ruffled to
: the side, accenting her figure.  She was standing there, her hands clasped
: in front of her, watching him from a distance.

: Kentaro smiled; then it faded away.  "You look beautiful."
: 
: Her eyes glinted.  Then she seemed to steel herself.  "Thank you."
: 
: Kentaro had trouble getting the words out.  "Does this mean what I think it
: means?"
: 
: Ranma licked her lips nervously.  "It means I'm willing to give it a try.
: No promises.  If that damn kettle appears, I use it in a flash.  But I...
: I'm not holding my breath any more."
: 
: Kentaro felt something rising in him, a kind of exultation he had never felt
: before.  "I'm glad."

: Ranma seemed to gather herself and stepped forward again.  "This is very
: difficult for me, Kentaro.  You can't imagine.  Guys... I just can't imagine
: being with guys in *that* way.  I'm only willing to try because it's *you*.
: You've been a good and patient friend, and you've helped me with some
: difficult times.  You even had the courage to say some things to me, things
: I needed to hear.  I couldn't hear them when Akane said them, or even when I
: said them to myself.  Somehow, it was different with you.  I don't know why.
: I'd like to find out.  If... if you can just continue to be patient."
: 
: Kentaro smiled gently.  "I've got all the time in the world, so long as
: you're here."
: 
: Ranma smiled nervously.  Then she closed her eyes and raised her chin.
: 
: Kentaro moved his lips towards hers, and this time she didn't pull away.

Hmmm.  I can kinda see this happening - except for the dress.  I
dunno; Ranma wearing a beautiful dress is harder to swallow for me
than Ranma deciding to give Kentaro a chance.  Shows what a
cesspool my mind is, I guess.  :)

I think it's a case of too much too fast.  Either change I could
have accepted, but not both, for some reason. <shrugs>


Sebastian
-- http://enterprise.mathematik.uni-essen.de/~bastian/ Comics reviewed.
-- Earth is a great funhouse without the fun. - Jeff Berner